Decriminalization is over. Recriminalization is the new trend.
On Wednesday, January 14th the Province confirmed what many people in the sector had suspected was coming: it was ending its limited decriminalization pilot program after three years.
Decriminalization was a provincial program that removed criminal penalties for adults possessing small amounts (2.5 g or less) of certain illegal substances for personal use. By decreasing the role of the criminal justice system in responding to substance use, the program was intended to reduce stigma and encourage access to health care and social services.
Despite public opinion on what the policy was or should have been, the program was proving successful and provincial data indicates that policy goals were being achieved. The Ministry of Health has reported that drug offences and seizures (key inhibitors of accessing services and ability to maintain housing and employment) decreased, and service use of programs like Overdose Prevention Sites were maintained or increased during the pilot program. By its own accord and measures, the provincial program was meeting its intended outcomes.
Decriminalization was an opportunity to address, however incompletely, the complex interplay between substance use, homelessness, and rising costs of living that force substance use into the public sphere.
The termination of the pilot program is a blow, not just to the thousands of people throughout the province who are navigating the toxic drug crisis on a daily basis. Instead of taking a leadership role against stigmatizing discourse, the province is folding to it; instead of acknowledging and working within the context of the unregulated toxic drug supply, we’re turning substance use into personal failure and punishment.
It’s also a blow to the values of the work being done to address the toxic drug supply in communities, and a strong indicator of where policy and resources are being directed. Where is person-centred care in this decision? How is the accessibility to services and supports being assisted by this decision, if people are now at risk of criminality by entering spaces intended to help them?
That decriminalization has ended is not a policy failure; it’s a societal failure. A return to criminalization allows us to continue to “other” and distance ourselves from people using substances, treat their health needs as a crime, and refuse to acknowledge our collective responsibility for each other’s wellbeing. Decriminalization is not the solution to toxic drugs, homelessness or rising costs of living, but is a necessary element of a much-needed comprehensive response to homelessness, and the unending toxic drug public health emergency. Now is not the time to take a step backward.
– Kim Markel, Executive Director